If I ever liked or loved to a murder that is only Rodian
Romanavich Rascolnicov,That’s the main character in Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoyevsky . It does not mean that I
like killing someone at any circumstance but I have an enigmatic love over
Rodian.
The Russian novnovelist , Fyodor Dostoyevsky‘s works are marked by a preoccupation with
Christianity, explored through the prism of the individual confronted with
life's hardships and beauty.
Even with that I can’t understand the intention of
killing someone.But inexplicably I m very much attached to him.over and over time to time I do read...
Looking for him......
But in Sri Lanka I
don’t think everyone feel the same way like me.what we hear is look like a
worst nightmares. We Sri Lankans now killing each other...
we did it for 30 years
and now we have started killing our neighbors....
I can’t understand what it is
going on. In prison over 1000 in raw to be executed. This is all killing
someone else. What about those who committed suicide. In Sri Lanka it’s a
crime? But we don’t have law abiding citizens. We have the highest rate of
commit suicide in the world.
Some cases there is no a particular reason, very recently
there was an incident the husband who works in abroad was talking with his wife
who was living in Sri Lanka. Somehow the skype conversation did not go
smoothly. The wife suddenly decided to commit suicide and hang herself while
the poor husband was looking through Skype. Believe this is a true story. This
look very strange, but I don’t think it is a sudden decision, frustration of long
term dull domestic life might have turned into an explosion.
Even as a very confused teenager I have got the intention of
commit suicide in few occasions. With careful observation of my mother and
regular counseling in “Sumithrayo “ I was able to survive so far.Now I don’t
think that I will ever turn back towards that moronic decision.
But last week I was on the process of reconciliation with my
memory, simply because I went to watch the Prasana Withanage’s new movie Oba Nathuwa Oba
Ekka (With You, Without You).This is a Sri Lankan
adaptation of novella “A Gentle Creature” by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Like Crime and
Punishment the story starts from a pawnbroker. Selvi who was frequent visitor to the shop and an orphan of the war. They married they as per the narrator in the
novella it explains the proposing was an attempt of triumph over her sad miserable
life.
“Besides, I had no
fears then: I knew that the fat shopkeeper was anyway more repulsive to her
than I was, and that I, standing at the gate, had appeared as a deliverer. I
understood that, of course. Oh, what is base a man understands particularly
well! But was it base? How can a man judge? Didn't I love her even then?”-A
Gentle Creature
But they married and
some extent they shared both good and bad moments like any
relationship but finally Selvi made her decision. But her decision was only reason
that made husband to think about her.
But when I was reading novella A gentle Creature I felt it
as a love story, May be not like Devdas, who killed himself up on love but it
was instead of fulfilling romantic ideals, it portrayed a battleground. Instead
of a tale of mutual happiness through mutual submission, it told of a power
struggle between the husband and wife. Despite the fact that the husband
possesses all of the story’s narrative time, it is his wife who, through her
death, eventually won the battle. From the beginning of the story the husband
tried controlling her. but what is worth wining something over a death of your own, In the movie it shown in bit straight forward way than the novella.May be I did not feel that way, either way husband did
try controlling her very much.
We could be very helpless due to various reasons, specially in front of your husband or partner very difficult to face it.but even we are helpless can we
accept over powering control always throughout the life?
Well in such situation we have two options, if we are strong enough we can walk away. Otherwise we have to follow the Selvi.In very literal way what Selvi did may be correct. Well the novella explains it and convinced the reader but in the movie?Well i should not have looked at the movie through the novella.
Well in such situation we have two options, if we are strong enough we can walk away. Otherwise we have to follow the Selvi.In very literal way what Selvi did may be correct. Well the novella explains it and convinced the reader but in the movie?Well i should not have looked at the movie through the novella.
But again I am worrying.
In Prasanna Withanage’s point this movie is an attempt of
exploring the masculinity. But I watched this with my mother. She has not read
the novella and she did not see noticeable masculinity of the husband, except
the limitation of their expenses for 300 RS per day.
Even she did not consider it as an attempt of over powering as in the novella she considers it as a good future plan.Being economical does not mean that we should live In Sri Lankan context it is a very common that husbands not attending to Sunday service or temple as a habitual action. People like my mother will never see it as a strong masculinity attempt.
Even she did not consider it as an attempt of over powering as in the novella she considers it as a good future plan.Being economical does not mean that we should live In Sri Lankan context it is a very common that husbands not attending to Sunday service or temple as a habitual action. People like my mother will never see it as a strong masculinity attempt.
This is a country which has higher rate of domestic violence,
due to adultery and use of alcohol. The film does not show any of these so even
husbands did not encourage wife to dance with the maid or singing it’s not a
huge issue.
People need to have certain level of understanding to consider other reasons apart from above mentioned.the long term believe in most of Sri Lankan housewives are if the husband
provides accommodation ,food and clothes they are willing to live without complain.
But there is a certain level who demands something more than that. Even 100
years ago Russian house wives have had social life. They go to theaters often
they have some sort of domestic maid helping with household. In Sri Lanka if
housewives had some social life most cases at the temple. Or else rarely movies.
We never had theaters on every town basis. The Russian adaptation might not
well fitted in
That may be the reason watching move only giving the idea
that Selvi made her decision based on trivial matters for average Sri Lankan
house wife. Well again how can I explain an average Sri Lankan House wife. I‘ll
try it somewhere in future.